Next pop-upOld Town Spring Farmers MarketSaturday · 11 AM – 4 PM · 318 Main/Prairie StDetails
Sugar Guilt Bakery
Order

Menu

Everything we bake.

Cookies are the headline, but the oven doesn't stop there. Tap anything that looks good and we'll start your order.

  • Half-dozen minimum per flavor
  • 24 hours' notice
  • 50% deposit locks in your date
Chocolate chunk cookies fresh from the oven

By the cookie

Thick, gooey and priced per cookie. Minimum ½ dozen per flavor, then add more in half-dozen steps.

9 flavors
Brown Butter Chocolate Chip$4.50

Brown Butter Chocolate Chip

A sweet and salty treat

Per cookie · ½ dozen minimumOrder →
Classic Chocolate Chunk$4.00

Classic Chocolate Chunk

Per cookie · ½ dozen minimumOrder →
Birthday Cake$3.00

Birthday Cake

Has that much love birthday cake flavor and a small hint of cardamom

Per cookie · ½ dozen minimumOrder →
Red Velvet Sugar Cookies$4.00

Red Velvet Sugar Cookies

Comes with white chocolate chip, cream cheese chips and Oreo cookies mixed in

Per cookie · ½ dozen minimumOrder →
Fruity Pebbles Cookies$4.50

Fruity Pebbles Cookies

Per cookie · ½ dozen minimumOrder →
Kitchen Sink Cookie$4.50

Kitchen Sink Cookie

Per cookie · ½ dozen minimumOrder →
Banana Bread$4.00

Banana Bread

Per cookie · ½ dozen minimumOrder →
Classic Snicker Doodle
$4.00

Classic Snicker Doodle

Per cookie · ½ dozen minimumOrder →
Chocolate Snickerdoodle
$4.00

Chocolate Snickerdoodle

Per cookie · ½ dozen minimumOrder →

By the batch

Bite-sized and old-fashioned favorites, priced as listed for a generous batch.

5 bakes
Cinnamon Swirl
$30.00

Cinnamon Swirl

Priced per batchOrder →
Icebox
$30.00

Icebox

These come in different flavors: Brown sugar walnut, Coconut Lime, Orange Poppyseed, Vanilla

Priced per batchOrder →
Italian Butter Cookies$30.00

Italian Butter Cookies

24 bite sized cookies per "dozen"

Priced per batchOrder →
Swedish Walnut Fingers
$28.00

Swedish Walnut Fingers

20 bite sized cookies

Priced per batchOrder →
Homemade Graham Crackers
$25.00

Homemade Graham Crackers

24 crackers

Priced per batchOrder →

Pastries & more

Cookie flavors for custom orders: Funfetti, Peanut Butter, Vanilla, Chocolate, Chocolate Chip.

1 item
Mini Almond Croissant$4.00

Mini Almond Croissant

A buttery, flaky croissant filled with sweet almond cream, topped with sliced almonds, and baked to golden perfection.

Per cookie · ½ dozen minimumOrder →

Muffins

Jumbo, bakery-style.

4 items
Blueberry Bliss Muffin
$5.00

Blueberry Bliss Muffin

A blueberry muffin layered with house-made blueberry jelly and covered with a buttery golden streusel crumble for the perfect sweet finish.

Per cookie · ½ dozen minimumOrder →
Chocolate Chip Indulgence Muffin
$4.00

Chocolate Chip Indulgence Muffin

A soft jumbo muffin loaded with rich chocolate chips throughout and baked golden on top for that classic bakery-style comfort.

Per cookie · ½ dozen minimumOrder →
Banana Comfort Muffin$4.50

Banana Comfort Muffin

A moist jumbo banana muffin made with ripe bananas and warm bakery spices for a rich homemade flavor customers love.

Per cookie · ½ dozen minimumOrder →
Strawberry Dream Muffin$5.00

Strawberry Dream Muffin

A tender jumbo muffin bursting with real strawberry flavor, topped with house-made strawberry rosemary jelly and a buttery crumble finish.

Per cookie · ½ dozen minimumOrder →

Cupcakes

Priced as listed. Some flavors contain alcohol.

9 items
Vanilla Bean Cupcakes$38.00

Vanilla Bean Cupcakes

Priced per batchOrder →
Pineapple Cupcakes
$35.00

Pineapple Cupcakes

Priced per batchOrder →
Moscow Mule Cupcakes
$50.00

Moscow Mule Cupcakes

Contains alcohol

Priced per batchOrder →
Mimosa Cupcakes$50.00

Mimosa Cupcakes

Contains alcohol

Priced per batchOrder →
Frappuccino Cupcakes
$34.00

Frappuccino Cupcakes

Priced per batchOrder →
Kahlúa Chocolate Cupcakes
$50.00

Kahlúa Chocolate Cupcakes

Contains alcohol

Priced per batchOrder →
Chocolate Cupcakes$35.00

Chocolate Cupcakes

Priced per batchOrder →
Vanilla Cupcakes$35.00

Vanilla Cupcakes

Priced per batchOrder →
Triple Secret Cupcakes
$40.00

Triple Secret Cupcakes

A Neapolitan-style cupcake layered with chocolate and vanilla topped with our smooth strawberry cream frosting for the perfect three-flavor indulgence in every bite.

Priced per batchOrder →

Market specials

Pop-up only. Seasonal items and breads rotate, so text us for what's baking this week.

See the next pop-up →
Double Chocolate Crunch
$4.50

Double Chocolate Crunch

Per cookie · ½ dozen minimumOrder →
Unicorn Berry Crunch
$4.00

Unicorn Berry Crunch

Per cookie · ½ dozen minimumOrder →

What's the hold up?

Mix and match your favorites and we'll bake a custom box made just for you. Your secret is safe with us.

Build my box Text us
Example site /sugar-guilt-bakeryDesigns by JoshBack to all projects